As credit reporting costs continue to rise, many mortgage lenders face a difficult decision: either absorb these cost increases or pass them along to their borrowers.
Passing along costs isn’t always the most strategic option, as today’s borrowers are already facing an expensive homebuying environment, marked by elevated home prices and persistently high mortgage rates. If you charge additional fees, it can make your loan offerings less competitive.
Fortunately, cost recovery isn’t your only option. By taking a closer look at how you order, manage, and use your credit reports, you may uncover opportunities to offset rising expenses without charging your borrowers more.
Below, we explore common operational inefficiencies that can drive up your credit reporting costs and three strategies to address them.
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- Rising credit reporting costs don’t necessarily have to translate into higher borrower fees. Improving your operational efficiency can help you offset some of these expenses.
- Unnecessary credit re-pulls, report reissues, and fragmented ordering processes can inflate your total credit reporting costs beyond the initial report fee.
- You can reduce unnecessary expenses by improving upfront ordering accuracy, strategically managing report validity windows, and consolidating your ordering processes with one credit provider.
What’s Driving Up Your Total Credit Reporting Costs?
If you haven’t optimized your credit report ordering process, you may be quietly incurring extra expenses due to the following inefficiencies:
#1 Unnecessary Credit Re-Pulls
A credit re-pull may be necessary for several reasons, such as obtaining updated credit information or satisfying underwriting requirements. However, some re-pulls take place due to preventable issues, such as:
- Incorrect borrower information: Submitting inaccurate borrower details may require your team to order additional credit pulls to obtain a correct report.
- Poorly timed refreshes: Ordering updated credit information before it’s necessary can inflate your costs, especially if you need another refresh closer to closing.
- Duplicate requests: When your team lacks visibility into your organization’s ordering activity, they may unknowingly request the same report multiple times.
Each unnecessary re-pull adds another fee to your loan file, and those additional charges can quickly add up across dozens or hundreds of loans.
Read More: Why Smart Credit Pulls Are the New KPI for High-Performing Mortgage Teams
#2 Avoidable Credit Report Reissue Fees
Credit report reissues allow you to share an existing report with another authorized party without ordering a completely new report. Depending on your provider’s pricing policies, these requests may carry additional fees.
While some reissues are necessary, it’s worth reviewing how frequently your team requests them and whether they could access existing reports without a reissue.
Understanding your provider’s reissue policies and coordinating report access across departments can also help you avoid unnecessary charges.
#3 Inefficient Ordering Across Multiple Systems
Ordering credit reports and related services through multiple systems can limit your team’s visibility into existing requests. This can lead to more duplicate orders, unnecessary administrative work, and inconsistent ordering practices.
For example, a loan processor may request a report without realizing that a loan officer already ordered it through a different platform, leading your organization to incur an unnecessary reporting fee. An occasional credit re-pull or duplicate order may seem like a relatively minor expense. However, when these issues occur repeatedly across your loan pipeline, the cumulative financial impact can be substantial.
For example, consider a lender that originates 100 loans per month. If just 20% of those files incur an additional $50 in avoidable credit reporting charges, that’s $1,000 in unnecessary monthly spending, or $12,000 annually.
Read More: One Relationship, Multiple Solutions: How the Right Credit Partner Can Strengthen Your Lending Operation
The Hidden Cost of Rework: Why Operational Efficiency Matters
To see how these inefficiencies can impact your overall credit reporting costs, let’s take a look at an example. Consider two loan files that require the same initial credit report:
- The first loan moves through your pipeline with accurate borrower information, timely ordering, and no unnecessary repeat requests.
- The second loan faces an initial ordering error, requires an additional pull, and generates a duplicate request from another team member who can’t see the original order.
While both loans started with the same base credit reporting fee, the second ultimately costs more due to the additional work involved.
3 Ways to Reduce Credit Reporting Costs Without Charging Borrowers More
Here are three ways to improve your credit report ordering strategy to streamline your expenses and protect your profit margins:
#1 Verify Accuracy Before Your Initial Credit Pull
Ensuring accurate orders upfront can help you reduce avoidable corrections and repeat requests later in the loan process. Before ordering a new credit report, make sure you’ve:
- Verified borrower names and identifying information
- Confirmed Social Security numbers and other required identifiers
- Checked current addresses and relevant address history
- Included the right borrowers in the request
You can also use tools like Certified Credit’s Flex ID SmartSelect Shield to verify critical borrower information before initiating a credit pull. By catching data-entry errors and identity discrepancies in advance, Flex ID can help you avoid unnecessary credit reporting expenses and reduce costly rework.
#2 Manage Validity Windows More Strategically
When it comes to mortgage underwriting, credit reports have a limited shelf life. Fannie Mae generally requires credit reports to be no more than four months old as of the note date, while Freddie Mac generally applies a 120-day limit for conventional loans.
While you may need to order replacement reports for loans that extend beyond these validity windows, doing so prematurely or more frequently than necessary can increase your expenses. To minimize avoidable re-pulls:
- Review the applicable credit report age requirements for each loan program.
- Track report dates alongside anticipated closing dates.
- Proactively identify loans approaching the end of their acceptable reporting windows.
- Coordinate necessary refreshes with underwriting and closing milestones.
By aligning your credit report refreshes with loan timelines and investor requirements, you can reduce unnecessary expenses while maintaining compliance.
#3 Consolidate Your Ordering Processes
Using multiple providers for credit reporting and verification services can complicate your ordering processes and make it harder to track existing requests. By consolidating these services with one provider, you can improve your team’s visibility and reduce the time they spend switching between multiple platforms.
Vendor consolidation can also help you identify opportunities to reduce costs across your lending operations. For example, at Certified Credit, we can evaluate your current product usage and explore ways to eliminate unnecessary expenses.
Read More: How Many Vendors Does It Really Take to Close a Mortgage?
Reduce Your Credit Reporting Costs With Certified Credit
While you can’t control rising credit reporting prices, you can take steps to reduce the unnecessary expenses that compound them. If you’re unsure where to start, Certified Credit can help you identify opportunities to save.
By partnering with us, you’ll gain access to our:
- Customizable credit reports: From single-bureau soft pulls to comprehensive tri-merge reports, we offer flexible credit reporting options to match each stage of your lending process.
- Ordering optimization expertise: Our workflow optimization experts can review your current credit ordering practices to identify inefficiencies and opportunities to reduce costs.
- Consolidated ordering: By consolidating your credit reports, verifications, and related services with us, you can simplify your workflows and streamline your vendor management.
Ready to reduce your credit reporting spend? Contact our team today to explore how we can help optimize your credit ordering strategy.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can mortgage lenders reduce credit reporting costs without charging borrowers more?
You can offset rising costs by identifying and eliminating avoidable expenses in your ordering process. You can do so by verifying borrower information before the initial credit pull, managing report validity windows to avoid premature refreshes, minimizing duplicate orders and reissue fees, and consolidating credit reporting and verification services with one provider.
What causes unnecessary credit re-pulls?
Common causes include incorrect borrower information, duplicate orders, poorly timed credit refreshes, and repeat requests for information that’s already available in other systems.
Can consolidating credit vendors reduce total reporting costs?
Yes. Consolidating vendors may help reduce your credit reporting costs by helping you eliminate duplicate orders, simplifying report access across your team, and improving your ordering efficiency. However, savings depend on your current processes, provider pricing, and product usage.
How long is a mortgage credit report valid?
For conventional mortgages, Fannie Mae generally requires credit reports to be no more than four months old as of the note date, while Freddie Mac applies a 120-day limit. Specific validity requirements may vary by loan program, so you should always verify the applicable underwriting and investor guidelines.
What operational changes can help reduce mortgage credit costs?
Start by ensuring accuracy upon the initial order, tracking report expiration dates, coordinating refreshes with closing milestones, and centralizing your ordering processes. You can also work with Certified Credit’s workflow optimization experts to evaluate your current practices and identify opportunities to improve efficiency and reduce costs.
Sources:
USA Today. Rising credit costs are squeezing homebuyers. Here’s what it means for you.
NAR. Research and Statistics.
https://www.nar.realtor/research-and-statistics?
Freddie Mac. Mortgage Rates.
https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms?
Fannie Mae. Selling Guide.
Freddie Mac. Age of documentation.